CCAR RESPONSA
New American Reform Responsa
75. Hannukah and Christmas Decorations in an Aprtment Complex
QUESTION: A large apartment building has both Jewish and Christian residents. Traditionally the foyer has been decorated with Christmas trees and wreaths. Recently the board has had requests for Hanukkah decorations as well as the menorah. Is this appropriate? (Teresa Dorfan, Kansas City MO)ANSWER: We have traditionally opposed both Hanukkah and Christmas decorations in public offices and schools. Although an apartment complex is somewhat different, it would probably also be best to follow this pattern in apartment buildings and leave religious celebrations to individuals. However the removal of Christmas decorations in this setting will only arouse animosity, so it may be better to add Hanukkah decorations to create a sense of fairness. There is nothing wrong with displaying a menorah in such a setting (see Responsa #76). Other decorations such as dreidels or colorful illustrations of the Maccabee story could also be used. We should remember that Hanukkah remains a minor holiday for us and, is not the equivalent of Christmas. The display of a menorah for Hanukkah would be appropriate in an apartment setting. It will add to the festivity of this holiday season.January 1989
If needed, please consult Abbreviations used in CCAR Responsa.